A student has exam anxiety. Before every exam he sleeps badly, in the exam room he gets dizzy, and sometimes his mind just goes blank. He wants to understand what's going on with him, and he starts reading.
The first book says: The anxiety has to do with an old inner conflict, maybe with early experiences he doesn't even remember. The second: It's about how he evaluates things. He thinks, "If I fail, I'm worthless." And that thought is what creates the anxiety. The third: You have to look at his family, at the expectations that have been running in the background there for years. The fourth: He's living by other people's standards and hasn't yet figured out what he himself wants.
After four books, he's more confused than before. So who's right?
Four schools, four questions
If you've read this series up to here, you may already have a hunch. The four books stand for four major schools of psychology, that is, four ways counselors and therapists look at a person. And each one asks its own question:
- Psychodynamic (depth) psychology asks: What is at work unconsciously?
- Cognitive behavioral therapy asks: How do I evaluate what happens?
- The systemic approach, which looks at family and relationships, asks: What pattern is running between us?
- Humanistic psychology asks: What does this person need in order to grow?
There are more, Transactional Analysis for example, and I've written about what lies behind the humanistic question in my article on the humanistic view of human nature. But four are enough to show the idea: these are four views of the same anxiety, and each one is right – in its own view.
What "right" means here
Just so there's no misunderstanding: I'm not claiming all four are factually equally correct. Whether an explanation fits this student, and how well which method works for exam anxiety – I don't want to judge that, and I can't. That's what research is for, and people who do this every day.
Both are right doesn't mean: everything is correct. It means: each one answers its own question – and whether the answer holds up is another question entirely.
So each school is right in its own view, because its answer fits its question. It's really just like the two colleagues from Part 1. She was asking about the law, he was asking about the money, and in their own view, neither of them was wrong.
Mediating, not unifying
You might get the idea now that the model in this series is meant to unify psychology. That would be too big for me, and it wouldn't be true either. The philosopher Ken Wilber once said, more or less, that everyone is right, but only partially, and built a big map out of that on which all the schools are supposed to find their place. My attempt is smaller: I see the model more as a mediator in between.
Between the schools, it does what the mediator in the last part did between the couple:
- It makes visible which question each school is asking.
- It recognizes each one, and none is placed above another.
- It shows where they talk past each other. When two books talk about "the family," one might mean an early memory deep inside, and the other a pattern that's still running today.
- It helps find bridges. Then the question is no longer: Which school is right? It becomes: Which question helps this person right now? Sometimes it's one, sometimes several together.
And maybe what Part 4 said about needs applies here too. When people argue about schools, a good part of what they're arguing about is strategies; the rest is a matter for research. Underneath, they all share the same need: to help people.
What matters to me here: the model doesn't stand above the schools. It's just one view itself, with its own question: Who is looking at what right now? It doesn't want to be more than that.
The model itself also changed while I was writing, bit by bit, partly through conversations. The "feeling" from Part 1, for example, I corrected in Part 5.
And me? There isn't necessarily one school I feel closest to. I find Marshall Rosenberg's Nonviolent Communication (NVC), which already came up in Part 4, very helpful: it helps you hear the feelings and needs behind accusations. I also find Viktor Frankl fascinating, with his focus on meaning, and Carl Gustav Jung, the founder of analytical psychology. All in all, there are a lot of fascinating approaches.
Both are right – the schools too.
And the student?
Maybe at some point he'll lay the four books side by side and notice that they contradict each other less than he thought. The sentence "If I fail, I'm worthless" can be an evaluation that comes from the expectations at home, and behind it there may be the question of what he actually wants for himself. He doesn't have to figure out on his own, just by reading, which question helps him most right now. He can look for someone who'll look at it with him, like in Part 8. In the end, deciding which answer fits him will be up to him. Carl Rogers gave this idea a lot of room – more on that in my article on client-centered therapy.
A look back
How did I come up with the model in the first place? The idea struck me when I noticed I was on the move in many areas at the same time. I was so immersed and focused, kind of like in a tunnel, that I first had to arrive back in the here and now, in what physically surrounds me. Since then, I've somehow been seeing the world as a kind of layers of realities lying side by side.
This series started with two people in a meeting who were talking past each other. After that it was about messages, about finer cuts, about needs and identity, then about the two sides within yourself, about people who turn into labels, and about those who help you look. And now about psychology.
The thought behind it has stayed the same: almost no one sees the whole of reality alone. That's why it's almost always worth asking which question the other person is looking with right now – and which one I'm looking with myself. Because the two who are right aren't always sitting at opposite ends of a table.
Thanks for looking along with me.
And you? Which question do you ask yourself most often when you want to understand what's happening inside you or between you and others? And which question have you maybe never asked? Feel free to write to me.