So the couple with the house is sitting at one table after all. Between them, a mediator. Neither of them really wants to be here. But both are tired of fighting.
The first hour sounds like the past year. Accusations, interruptions, "That's just not true." At one point she gets up and walks out; a few minutes later she comes back. The mediator interrupts sometimes too. But she doesn't judge. She sorts.
Untangling a tangle
A hardened conflict is rarely just one conflict. Usually it's a tangle of several that have gotten caught up in each other. With the couple, you can pull out at least four threads, each from a different view:
- Law: Who owns the house, and who gets to keep living in it?
- Money: Who put how much into it?
- Time: Who planned, renovated, took care of things?
- Relationship: How will the two of them still talk to each other once everything is settled?
Underneath, there's one more question, which isn't really a view, because it's tied to who the two of them are. It already came up in Part 5: Did what I did count? This need for recognition pulls on every one of the threads.
As long as everything lies in one tangle, you can't talk about any single point without dragging all the others along. Talk about money and you hit recognition at the same time, and talk about time and you quickly end up at the question of who you actually are.
What the mediator does
Really, she keeps doing the same few things over and over. First, she makes visible which question is in the room right now: "Are we talking about the money right now – or about whether your work was seen?"
Then she lets each of them finish and tells them back what she heard, until they nod. She isn't siding with one against the other. But each of them hears that their view has landed, and I think that's what makes it possible, at some point, to listen to the other one again.
And she notices where the two of them are talking past each other. At some point both say the same sentence: "I put more into this house." She means the money, he means the time. The same sentence comes from two views, and that's why each thinks the other is being outrageous, until the mediator pulls it apart.
What is my part?
In one of the later sessions, the old circle from Part 7 comes up again. She says: "I pull back because he keeps pushing." He says: "I keep pushing because she keeps pulling back." Both are waiting for the mediator to say who started it. Instead, she asks them both: "What would your part in this circle be?"
At first it's quiet, and it takes a while before one of them answers. Still, the question is easier to bear than the one that was in the room before:
Blame asks: Who did it? Responsibility asks: What is my part?
With blame, someone has to lose in the end, so everyone defends themselves as long as they can. You can look at your own part without losing face, because the other person has theirs too. I think that's why the blame question loses its force as soon as a conflict gets some structure: once the threads are laid out side by side, you see that usually both of them were pulling.
Asking about my own part has helped me, too.
One view at a time – and sometimes several at once
Now each thread can be looked at on its own. The numbers on the money can be checked; what holds legally, a lawyer can tell you. The relationship probably needs the most time.
And then the mediator looks for bridges, meaning a solution that carries more than one thread. With the couple, it might look like this: He stays in the house and buys out her share. The agreement also states that she paid off the house for twenty years, and that he planned every room and saw every contractor through. That doesn't really cost anything, but it answers the question of recognition, and for both of them. And because it's answered, suddenly they can talk about the money.
A solution like that takes care of several threads in one go.
Whether it's the right solution for the two of them isn't up to the mediator. That's up to them.
So who's actually leading here?
The last part was about how helping doesn't mean handing out solutions. And now here's a mediator sorting, interrupting, and asking uncomfortable questions. Isn't that a contradiction?
I don't think so. The mediator leads the conversation, not the outcome. She makes sure every question gets its place and nobody goes under. What the two of them answer to those questions is their business. In my article on counseling approaches, this is called process consulting: someone accompanies the way, but the person finds the solution themselves.
Spaces for people
I come from software and information architecture, and even there, structure doesn't make me think of control first. I think of spaces. A good space doesn't tell anyone how to live. But it makes some things easier: light where you read, quiet where you sleep, room where you meet.
That's how I see structure in a conflict, too. It doesn't make people's decisions for them. It creates the space where they can meet again.
Good structure takes pressure off people.
In the last part, I'd like to apply the idea of this series to something completely different: psychology itself.
And you? Was there a conflict that got easier as soon as someone helped sort it out? Feel free to write to me.