Remember the meeting from the first part? A colleague says, "We're not allowed to do it this way." Another colleague replies, "If we don't do it, it's going to cost us serious money."
By now we know: they're looking from different views. She's asking "Is this allowed?", he's asking "Does this make economic sense?" But why are both of them holding on so tightly to their question? Why won't either one let go?
I think the answer lies behind the arguments.
What's behind the arguments
She probably needs security. She doesn't want to be held liable, and she wants to be able to stand behind what she does. He probably needs security, too: that his department makes its numbers and he isn't left empty-handed next quarter.
So really, both need the same thing. That doesn't stop them from going on arguing, though.
In Nonviolent Communication, his approach to honest conversations without blame, Marshall Rosenberg put weight on an idea that helps here: we all share the same needs, security or recognition, for example. What differs are the strategies, the ways in which we try to meet a need. The Harvard approach from Getting to Yes, a well-known method for negotiation, says something similar: behind positions there are interests. "Do it" and "don't do it" are strategies. Security is the need.
Security isn't always the same security
What I'd like to add here is a small shift. The need is the same for both of them. But where it's under threat is different. For her, the insecurity comes up in the view Law, for him in the view Money.
By the way, it's similar with the two and the machine from the last part. She doesn't want a hole in the budget this year. He doesn't want to be working with a machine that keeps breaking down three years from now. That's probably about security, too. Only for those two, it starts out in the same view, Money, and only splits one level further down. With Law and Money, it sits in two different places from the start.
That makes a difference, because it decides what actually helps:
| Where the insecurity comes up | What helps |
|---|---|
| in the view Law | a clear rule, a review, a sign-off |
| in the view Money | numbers, a plan, a buffer |
| in the view Time | a fixed date, a schedule that holds |
| in the relationship | being heard, recognition |
If you answer a legal worry with a calculation showing it pays off, you've recognized the need, but you're answering it in the wrong place. "Don't worry, it'll pay for itself" doesn't reassure her. To her, it feels more like he wasn't listening at all.
I know this from myself, too. Well-meant reassurance that lands in the wrong place often makes things worse rather than better.
What "being right" means here
Since this series is called "Both Are Right," a word on that. I don't mean that everything is correct and everyone just has their own truth.
What I mean is: each of them is answering their own question. She's right that the legal question is open. He's right that money plays a role. Whether the legal situation really is that way in the end, and whether the numbers add up, is yet another question. For that you have to check, or ask experts. No model can do that.
Whether it's factually true is something I neither want to nor can judge, either. The model helps you see from which view someone is right. And often that's already enough to get people talking to each other again.
More than two options
For me, this is where the biggest gain lies. As long as the two are arguing about "do it" or "don't do it," there are exactly two options, and one of them loses.
As soon as they see that both need security, she legally and he financially, the question changes: How do we get both? Then things come up that nobody was looking for before. You can try it on a small scale first and have it checked legally beforehand. You can roll it out in steps or plan a buffer into the budget.
Nobody gave in. Both just stopped arguing about strategies.
If you know where the worry sits, you'll find more than two ways forward.
For a conversation, that means it's worth asking not just "What do you need?" but also "Where exactly are you missing security?" Only then can you answer in a way that actually lands. There's more on how to put feelings and needs into words in my article Communicate Better with I-Statements.
In the next part it gets more personal: why some arguments get so heated that no question and no need can get through anymore.
And you? Was there an argument where you realized afterward that you both actually wanted the same thing? Feel free to write to me.