Back to the meeting from the first part. This time, we're only looking at the colleague, just before she says, "We're not allowed to do it this way."

Inside her, it's louder than in the room. One voice says: If this goes wrong, I'm on the hook too. I have to bring it up. Another says: Me again. They already think I'm the one who always puts on the brakes.

Both voices are right.

Two views, one person

You usually know this kind of thing from between two people. In the view Law, the colleague needs security: not doing anything wrong, not being liable. In the view Belonging, she needs backing: being liked by the others, not being the one who slows everything down.

Those are two needs in two different places, and they pull in opposite directions.

The outline of a single person. Inside her two views: Law – she needs security, “not doing anything wrong” – and Belonging – she needs backing, “not being the brake”. Between the two a taut thread; the two views pull in opposite directions. LawBelongingSecurity“not doing anything wrong”Backing“not being the brake”
Figure 6Two views that contradict each other – in one person.

So what happens in the meeting? Often something that's hard to understand from the outside. Because she hasn't settled the fight inside, she carries it out into the room. She argues more sharply than the matter calls for – partly to drown out the second voice inside her. Her colleague gets the full force of a conflict that isn't really just between the two of them.

The Inner Team

Friedemann Schulz von Thun, who already came up in the second part with the four sides of a message, found a nice image for this: the Inner Team. Several voices often speak inside us, for example a cautious one and one that wants to belong. None of them is wrong. Each one stands for something that matters to us.

I know this too. For me, it's sometimes the voice that wants to think something through properly and the one that finally wants to deliver. Both are right.

Schulz von Thun also made the values square well known. The idea goes back to the philosopher Nicolai Hartmann and the psychologist Paul Helwig: every value needs a sister virtue to keep it in balance. Caution needs courage. Belonging needs the willingness to be inconvenient now and then. Things only get difficult when one of the two values rules alone. Then caution turns into fearfulness, and courage into recklessness.

In the terms of this series: the voices in the Inner Team look from different views. And just as between two people, the same holds here: none of them is more important than the other from the outset.

First within, then between us

This leads to a thought that matters to me. When I feel a contradiction inside me, it's worth looking at it with myself first. What does one voice want? What does the other want? Is there something that does justice to both?

I notice this in myself: when I'm unclear inside, it's hard for me to focus on the person in front of me.

For the colleague, this could turn into a sentence that lets both voices have their say:

"I don't want to hold up the project. I just want to be sure we're allowed to do it. Can we have that checked quickly?"

That way she's no longer on the defensive. She says what question she has and what worry is behind it. Her colleague doesn't have to argue against a wall. He can answer a question.

First sort it out within, then between us.

I mean this as an offer, not a rule. Not every inner contradiction can be sorted out beforehand. Sometimes things only become clear inside once you talk about them outside. Then the conversation itself is the place where you find out what you actually want. That's fine too. The only important thing is that you notice: Part of this fight is happening inside me right now.

What this changes

People who notice this in themselves often become gentler – with themselves and with others. Because if I know that two voices inside me are right, I can also imagine it's the same for the other person. The colleague who insists so hard on the money may also be struggling with a second voice he isn't saying out loud.

And it takes the pressure off. I no longer have to defeat one of the voices. I can listen to both – and then decide.

In the next part, we'll look at what happens when a fight goes on so long that we no longer see a person in the other at all.

What about you? Do you know an inner contradiction where both sides in you are right? Feel free to write to me.

The scenes are condensed from everyday moments. Details have been changed.