The couple with the house from Part 5 is a year further down the road now. They hardly talk about the house anymore. Now it's about everything.
When she talks about him, she says: "That's just how he is. He's always been like that." When he talks about her, he says: "You can't talk to her."
Both of them mean it. And at some point, both of them stopped seeing the other as a person who can change.
A circle with no beginning
How does it get this far? Rarely through a single fight. Usually through a whole chain of conflicts, each one building on the last.
One pattern is especially stubborn. She says: "I pull back because he keeps pushing." He says: "I keep pushing because she keeps pulling back."
Who started it? In their own view, each of them is right, because each puts the starting point at something the other did. Paul Watzlawick described exactly this example decades ago: a circle like this has no beginning. Each person experiences themselves only as reacting to the other.
The roughest cut of all
Part 3 was about how finely you divide up a situation. What happens here could be called the roughest cut of all. A whole person gets reduced to a single trait, often even to a single moment that hurt especially badly.
"That's just how he is" sounds like an observation. Really, it's a label. The other person becomes a thing with fixed properties, a thing that doesn't move anymore.
The conflict researcher Friedrich Glasl described how a conflict escalates step by step until the other person has become an enemy image and you expect nothing but the worst from them. The label is one of those steps. Once you think "That's just how he is," what you mostly see afterward is whatever fits.
People are always becoming
And yet it's almost never true that someone has "always been like that." People are not things. A person is never really finished; they change all the time. The person I am today could be someone quite different tomorrow, especially when strong influences are at work on me. A breakup is one of those strong influences.
I think fixed pictures like this form in everyone now and then, more strongly in some, less in others. What matters is recognizing them as pictures and not mistaking them for the person.
Who someone is today, they may not be tomorrow.
That's why the model in this series describes processes, not people. You can describe a process without pinning anyone down. We talk about the process – not because the other person doesn't matter, but so they don't get turned into the problem.
This matters to me from a humanistic point of view. I've written about what's behind it in my article on the humanistic worldview. There's a sentence in it that fits well here: The human being is more than the sum of parts. A label takes a single part and acts as if that were the whole person.
So for me, there's one point where the weighing of views stops. The other person's dignity is not up for a vote. It isn't a view you weigh against others. It's the ground that makes the weighing possible in the first place.
A small crack in the label
What can you do when you notice a label like that in yourself? Not much all at once. But something small: look for an exception.
Was there a moment when he wasn't like that?
In solution-focused counseling, following Steve de Shazer and Insoo Kim Berg, this is called the exception question. There's almost always a moment like that. And that one moment is enough for a small crack. Through it, the other person becomes a little more of a human being again, someone you can talk to – or at least someone you have more than just a verdict about.
How you can help someone who is stuck like this is what the next part is about.
And you? Have you ever noticed that you'd reduced someone to a label – and then they surprised you? Feel free to write to me.