A friend calls. She's fallen out with her sister over caring for their mother. She talks for twenty minutes straight.
And you? Three minutes in, you know what she should do. "Why don't you just tell her …" is on the tip of your tongue. Or: "Well, your sister's always been like that."
Either would be well meant. It probably wouldn't help her much.
I know that impulse in myself. But sometimes it's good to just take things in first and give the person room. Of course, that doesn't always work in the rush of everyday life.
Why good advice rarely helps
Advice has a problem: it comes from my view. I see one piece of the situation, and from that piece I build a solution. But she is right in the middle of it, with lots of views I can't see at all: the history between the two sisters, her guilty conscience, what her mother means to her.
And she may be caught in an inner contradiction, like in Part 6: one voice in her wants to set boundaries. Another wants to be a good daughter. Only she can resolve that contradiction; it can't be done from the outside.
That doesn't make advice wrong in principle. If she wants to know how to apply for a care level for her mother, knowledge is really what helps her most. That's why counseling distinguishes between expert consulting, which provides knowledge, and process consulting, which accompanies someone while they sort things out; I've described the difference in my article on different approaches to counseling. In this fight, she needs the second kind more.
If you hand over the solution anyway, you can easily slip into a role transactional analysis calls the Rescuer. The Rescuer means well, but makes the other person small: You can't do this on your own, I'll do it for you. I've written about this role in my article on the drama triangle.
What helps instead
So what does help? For me, it's something unspectacular: looking together.
Carl Rogers, the founder of client-centered therapy, shaped this attitude. Roughly, his idea is that people are the experts on their own lives. Whoever helps creates the space in which they find their own answer. More on this in my article on client-centered therapy.
Looking together works over the phone, too. Inwardly, you sit down next to your friend and look at the situation together with her, instead of handing her a verdict from across the table. And you ask more than you answer:
"What matters most to you in all this?"
"Where exactly does it hurt – the caregiving itself, or the way your sister talks to you?"
"What would you wish for if anything were possible?"
Questions like these help sort things out. They help pull apart the views that are getting tangled up in the conversation: the time the caregiving takes, the money, fairness between the sisters, the worry about their mother. And often your friend notices for herself which of them weighs heaviest right now. There's more about good questions in my article Questions.
Two things to avoid
There are two traps when you look together.
The first is attributions. "Your sister's always been selfish" feels supportive. But it turns the sister into a thing with a fixed trait – exactly what Part 7 was about. And it makes it harder for your friend to talk to her again later.
The second is losing contact. If you're helping, you have to stay with the other person, even when it gets emotional. So don't rush to smooth things over, and don't veer off into your own story. Just be there while she sorts things out.
At those moments, I try to take an attitude of understanding and build understanding. To be honest, that's not always easy.
Helping doesn't mean solving – it means looking together.
And in the end?
By the end of the call, your friend may not have a solution. But she's clearer about what matters to her. Maybe she sees an option that wasn't there before. Whether she takes it is up to her. A solution always has to be accepted by the person who has the conflict.
Looking together has its limits, too. If your friend is noticeably at the end of her strength, a good talk between friends sometimes isn't enough, and it's certainly no substitute for therapy. Then the best step is really to think together about where she can get professional help.
But what if two people are so tangled up that they can't find their way out on their own? Then sometimes it takes someone who helps both of them look – that's what the next part is about.
And you? When did someone last help you without telling you what to do? Feel free to write to me.